Penis Pumps Vs Penis Extenders: Which is Better?

For men seeking solutions for issues like erectile dysfunction or small penis size, devices like penis pumps and penile extenders promise non-surgical approaches. Penis pumps use suction to draw blood into the penis before sex, offering temporary relief of erectile dysfunction. Penis extenders use gentle traction to stretch the penis over time, with the goal of increasing length permanently.

With many options on the market making similar claims, it can be hard to know which type of device may be right for you. This article will break down how penis pumps and extenders work, their potential benefits and drawbacks, and what to consider before purchasing one. We’ll look at factors like cost, required usage, safety, and possible side effects.

Whether you’re looking to improve erections, add length, or correct a curvature, understanding these devices can help set realistic expectations. While pumps and extenders have their places, they may not be long-term or catch-all solutions.

We’ll also explore why consulting a medical professional is advised before beginning use of either gadget, especially if you have an underlying condition. With the facts laid out on both options, you can make a more informed choice about which device suits your needs and comfort level.

What Are Penis Pumps?

Penis pumps are vacuum devices that work by creating suction around the penis, causing blood to rush into the erectile tissues. A basic pump consists of a tube or cylinder that fits over the penis, with a manual or motorized pump attached to remove air from inside the tube.

As air (or water) is pumped out, a partial vacuum is created, which draws blood into the penis, engorging the erectile tissues and causing an erection. Most penis pumps have a compression ring or constriction band that can be placed at the base of the penis to restrict blood flow out of the erection once it is achieved.

Penis pumps are non-invasive devices that do not require surgery, medication, or injections. They can be purchased without a prescription and used in the privacy of home. Some men with erectile dysfunction rely on penis pumps as a treatment option due to their lower cost and ease of use compared to medications, injections, or other treatments.

Penis pumps are also sometimes used for temporary enlargement or to exercise the penis when combined with other therapies. It’s important to use them properly to avoid injury and know that regular use is required to maintain results.

 See Also: How to Use a Hydro Penis Pump For Long-Term Results 

Benefits of Penis Pumps

Using a penis pump can provide a number of potential benefits for men seeking to enlarge or improve the function of their penis:

  • Helps reduce ED symptoms – Penis pumps can assist in achieving erections for those with erectile dysfunction. The suction action draws blood into the erectile tissues of the penis, engorging them to become firm. This provides the temporary rigidness needed for sexual intercourse.  Penis pumps can also be helpful for those with other conditions that interfere with erections, like diabetes, prostate cancer treatment, or neurological disorders.
  • Non-invasive with minimal side effects – Because penis pumps are non-invasive and have no chemicals or drugs involved, they can be used frequently without worry of side effects. They are considered safe for frequent use.
  • May improve penile blood flow over time – The vacuum effect may improve penile blood circulation over time with regular use.
  • Erections may feel more rigid and last longer – Some users experience an improved quality of erections, and report that erections achieved with a pump feel more rigid and last longer.
  • More affordable option – Penis pumps tend to be more affordable than medications and other erectile dysfunction treatments. After purchasing, there are no recurring costs or pharmacy fees. A penis pump can be also be reused for years with proper cleaning and care, unlike medications with recurring costs.
  • Provides immediate results – The pumps can also provide immediate results – there’s no waiting for a pill to take effect.
  • Useful alternative for those unable to take ED medications – For men uncomfortable using medications or who cannot take pills due to health conditions, penis pumps offer a drug-free alternative.
  • Drug-free approach available without prescriptions: Penis pumps can be purchased discreetly and used privately at home.

Potential Drawbacks of Penis Pumps

While penis pumps can help some men with erectile dysfunction, there are several potential drawbacks to consider as well:

  • The erection effects are temporary – After removing the penis pump device, the erection will subside within 30 minutes to an hour. It does not provide a permanent fix for erectile issues.
  • Overpumping can cause bruising or numbness – Using too much pressure or vacuum strength can damage delicate penile tissues, leading to blotchy bruising or loss of sensation.
  • Not a permanent enlargement solution – Penis pumps may temporarily make the penis appear larger from swelling, but effects dissipate quickly once pumping stops. No permanent size increase results from using a pump.
  • Can cause penile pain – Some men experience aching, discomfort, or pain from the suction pressure. This may require adjusting the pump settings or stopping use.
  • Requires discipline for best results – To avoid injury and achieve the best erections, following pump directions and maintaining a routine are essential.
  • Not recommended for men with certain conditions – Those with severe penile vascular disease, sickle cell anemia, or bleeding disorders could further injure themselves using a penis pump.
  • May interfere with ejaculation – Pumping can make it more difficult to orgasm or ejaculate if used with a cock ring at the base of the penis.

Bathmate penis pump results

What are penile extenders?

Penis extenders, also called penile traction devices, are non-invasive tools designed to gently stretch the penis over an extended period of time, with the goal of adding length and girth. They consist of a plastic support ring that fits around the base of the penis, two dynamic metal rods that run along the top and bottom of the shaft, and a silicone or rubber comfort strap to hold the penis in place. The rods can be lengthened by adjusting the telescopic bars, creating tension that stretches the penile tissues.

Much like strength training builds muscles slowly over time, the constant stretch forces the cells in the penis to divide and multiply, promoting new tissue growth. As the cells divide and expand, the penis is able to accommodate more blood, gradually increasing size both when flaccid and erect.

Penile extenders are meant to be worn for several hours per day for a period of months to years. Unlike penis pumps which have a temporary effect, penile extenders aim for permanent enlargement when used regularly. However, results will fade if use of the extender is discontinued.

When purchasing an extender, it’s critical to choose a high-quality medical device and follow product instructions carefully to avoid injury.

Benefits of using penile extenders

Using a penile extender can offer several potential benefits for men seeking to enlarge or lengthen their penis:

  • Can increase flaccid/erect penis size – With regular use over months, penile traction can gradually increase length and girth by forcing the tissues to grow new cells. Some studies show average growth of 0.5 to 2 inches in length.
  • Non-invasive approach – Penile extenders use gentle traction rather than chemicals, injections or invasive procedures to stimulate tissue growth over time. This makes them an accessible option for size enhancement.
  • Does not require constant use – Penile extenders only need to be worn for 4-6 hours daily to produce results when used for the recommended period of months to a year.
  • Corrects penile curvature – The steady extending traction can help straighten curved erections in men with Peyronie’s disease. This may reduce penis deformity without surgery.
  • Minimal side effects – Unlike surgery which carries risks, penile extenders are unlikely to cause complications when used properly. There may be temporary soreness, itching, or bruising.
  • Cheaper than surgical enlargement – High-quality extenders cost hundreds of dollars as opposed to the high expense and medical risks of surgical penis augmentation.
  • Results are permanent if use continues – The size gains from an extender last for life, as long as you maintain a regular schedule of use. If stopped, the penis will gradually return to its original size.

Potential cons of using penile extenders

While penile extenders present a less invasive option for increasing size, there are some potential drawbacks to consider:

  • Requires patience and discipline – Seeing noticeable results takes consistent use over months. Men may grow discouraged by the slow pace of growth.
  • Can rub or chafe – The comfort strap holds the penis in place, but may cause irritation from friction against the skin.
  • Not a cure for erectile dysfunction – Extenders enlarge size but do not treat issues achieving or maintaining erections.
  • Daily use is needed – The constant stretching only works if the extender is worn for several hours per day according to directions.
  • Size increase may be minimal – Results vary with genetics and age. For some men, growth may be under an inch.
  • Can cause pain if overused – Going beyond the recommended daily usage or traction level can lead to soreness, blisters, or injury.
  • Not suitable for men with certain conditions – Those with severe circulatory disorders, urinary tract issues, or penile implants should avoid penile extenders.
  • Effects are temporary without continued use – Once you stop the traction program, the penis will gradually revert to its former size.
  • Proper device sizing is crucial – Extenders that are poorly fitted or the wrong size can slip off or cause penile damage.

Penile traction device for lengthening and straightening the penis.

Overview of Pros and Cons

Penis Pump Pros

  • Can help achieve erections for those with ED
  • Non-invasive with minimal side effects
  • Provides immediate results
  • Improves size and blood flow over time with regular use
  • Typically more affordable than medications/other treatments
  • Drug-free and available without prescription

Penis Pump Cons

  • Immediate erection effects are temporary
  • Overpumping can cause swelling, bruising, pain or discomfort.
  • Requires regular use for lasting results
  • Not recommended for some medical conditions
  • May interfere with ejaculation if using a cock ring

 Click Here to See Our #1 Rated Penis Pump >> 

Penis Extender Pros

  • Can increase flaccid and erect penis length over time
  • Non-invasive approach to enlargement
  • Can help correct penile curvature
  • Minimal side effects when used properly
  • Cheaper alternative to surgery

Penis Extender Cons

  • Requires patience and persistence to see results
  • Does not treat erectile dysfunction
  • Can cause pain, numbness or discomfort if not properly used
  • Not suitable for some medical conditions
  • Requires consistent, regular use for results

 Click Here to Reveal Our #1 Rated Penis Extender >> 


In reviewing the key differences between penis pumps and penile extenders, both devices offer potential benefits but also have their limitations. Penis pumps provide an immediate, short-term fix for erectile dysfunction through vacuum suction, but carry risks like pain or bruising if overused.

They may not permanently increase size. Penile extenders take a gentle, gradual approach to penile lengthening over months through traction. But results require diligent daily use and gains will recede without continued occasional use ( once or twice a week) to maintain your gains.

Ultimately, both penis pumps and extenders may offer permanent solutions for noticeable penis enlargement, and could help improve underlying conditions like erectile dysfunction or Peyronie’s disease. However, while preliminary evidence shows both can have significant value for some men, the  benefits may be more modest for others.

Men should have realistic expectations about potential results. It is advisable to consult a doctor about the pros, cons, safe usage, and alternatives before beginning use of pumps or extenders.

Regardless of which device you choose, they are far better options than surgical penis augmentation which carries significantly greater risks. That said, non-surgical treatments should not replace lifestyle changes, medications, or therapy where clinically indicated.

With a thoughtful approach and open communication with a physician, men can weigh if gentle penile traction or vacuum erection assistance fit into an overall plan for sexual health and confidence.

 See Also: Real Penis Enlargement – The Top 5 Best Ways to Increase Your Size 


Are penis pumps or extenders better for treating erectile dysfunction?

Penis pumps offer immediate, short-term relief of erectile dysfunction by using vacuum suction to draw blood into the penis before sex, causing a larger, firmer erection. However, this effect fades after a few hours, but over time with continued use becomes more permanent.

Penis extenders are not designed to treat ED as they focus on gradual size enhancement – primarily length only. For long-term ED treatment, options like medications or natural ED supplements may be more effective.

Is it safe to use a penis pump if I have a medical condition?

Men with severe heart disease, sickle cell anemia, bleeding disorders or other penile issues should avoid using penis pumps, as the vacuum pressure can lead to bruising, numbness or further injury. Consult a doctor before use.

Can using a penile extender really increase my penis size?

Studies show consistent use of a quality penile extender over 4-6 months can incrementally increase length and girth for some men. However, patient anatomy, genetics, and adherence to directions play a role in results. Not all men respond equally.

What results can I expect from using a penis pump or extender?

For pumps, immediate but temporary enlargement from swelling may be visible. For extenders, a potential gain of 0.5 to 1 inch length may occur slowly over months of daily traction for some. However, individual results vary widely.

How long per day do I need to use a penile traction device to see results?

Penile extenders should be worn for 4-6 hours per day, for a minimum of 3-6 months to potentially see a measurable increase in length according to product guidelines. This requires dedication and consistently wearing the device.

Are there less invasive options for penis enlargement or erectile dysfunction?

Yes, medications, injections, counseling, and lifestyle changes may help with ED or dissatisfaction with size for some men. Discuss all treatment alternatives with a doctor to determine the best personalized solution based on your health profile and goals.

Leave a Comment